Calls to FXO ring FXS instead of going out the trunk

I've got Trixbox Pro SE server 100827 with a TDM400 (2 FXS and 2 FXO).

Prior to today, I was using 1 analog phone, 1 SIP phone and some Softphones - no analog lines.

I also have two VOIP providers, which I've been using and have been able to test most of my functionality with (along with 1 analog phone).

I now have two analog phones on Ports 1 & 2 (FXS) and one analog line on Port 3 (FXO). Port 4 is not used (FXO).

Inbound calls on the analog line (Port 3) work fine.
Extension to extension (analog or SIP) work fine.
Extensions (analog or SIP phones) to outside calls work fine over VOIP
I don't have an inbound DID through the VOIP quite yet - but that should work.

The dial Plan allows me to assign "Analog lines 3 (2)" as a primary outbound route. (I'm not sure what the "3 (2)" means, hopefully it means Port 3 with 2 possible Analog outbound lines?)

The plan is to use the Analog line as the primary outbound route, but when I dial it (e.g., 9nxxnxxxxxx now has "analog lines 3 (2) selected as it's primary) from SIP or analog phones it rings the analog phone on Port 1.

If I call out on the Analog phone (port 1) that just rang, it rings the other analog phone (port 2).

odd...
I read through most of the relevant Trixbox Pro help, but didn't see anything that helped.

I set up 3 dial plans to 1800free411, two through my VOIPs and one through the Phone Line to test, and it keeps doing the same thing.

I moved the Phone Line to port 4, same thing.

Help would be great...
Bob